ShanghaiDoctor

Seeking Healing Across Borders|Cross-Border Medical Trust and Renewed Life

更新时间:2025-02-01点击:1109


The issue of “difficulty in accessing medical care” is akin to a chronic societal ailment, seemingly incurable for us. The dissatisfaction and complaints from patients towards hospitals and doctors have almost become a habitual response.

However, after visiting a foreign friend in the Neurosurgery Department of Shanghai Fourth People’s Hospital, we discovered that the Chinese medical environment, often criticized and complained about by patients, appears in a completely different light to them. Ms. S, who hails from Europe, and her spouse candidly admitted that, compared to the situation abroad, patients in China are actually quite fortunate.

image.png




Part 1

Fourteen Years of Agony:The Torment of Trigeminal Neuralgia


Ms. S, a young woman from Europe, has long been tormented by the excruciating pain of trigeminal neuralgia. This pain, often described as “the most severe pain a human can endure,” has made every day of the past fourteen years a precarious walk on thin ice, forcing her to bear an agony that is hard for the average person to comprehend. In the summer of 2024, Ms. S, with hopes for the future, accompanied her Chinese husband back to Shanghai to visit family, marking her first journey to China. However, this family visit did not bring her the anticipated joy; instead, the intensification of her pain plunged her into deeper despair. “Every time I ate, washed my face, or even spoke, it would trigger intense pain,” Ms. S recalled. “I felt as if I were trapped in an endless nightmare.”

Abroad, Ms. S had nearly exhausted all advanced medical equipment and methods, undergoing multiple CT and MRI scans, yet no doctor could provide an accurate diagnosis. This long and arduous journey for medical help was fraught with obstacles and despair. “In foreign countries, you first need to see a general practitioner, who then refers you to a specialist based on the examination reports,” explained Ms. S’s husband. “Ms. S’s first stop was the dental department, and we waited three months for an appointment with a dentist.” Finally, Ms. S met with the dentist, who suggested extracting a tooth suspected of causing the pain and replacing it with a dental implant. However, the pain did not improve; instead, it became more intense. “I endure this pain every day, and my life has become devoid of quality,” Ms. S lamented. Subsequently, Ms. S underwent a series of examinations and was referred to the cardiology department. Despite detailed checks, no heart issues were found. She was then transferred to the pain management department, where, even after numerous tests, no clear conclusion was reached. The doctors recommended some painkillers, but these did not alleviate her symptoms and instead brought more side effects. 

“In the pain management department, the doctors said it might be a complex pain issue, but the specific cause remained unclear,” Ms. S stated. “They suggested I return to the dental department.” Back in the dental department, the doctor recommended extracting two more healthy teeth and replacing them with implants. Yet, this did not solve the problem; Ms. S’s pain persisted. She was nearly drained of all patience and hope, her spirits sinking day by day. 

In search of further answers, Ms. S visited the neurology department at a community clinic. The doctor arranged an MRI (Magnetic Resonance Imaging) scan, but surprisingly, even experienced neurologists did not detect the issue of vascular compression on the right side. They merely brushed it off as ordinary neuralgia and prescribed some painkillers. Ms. S took the medication as directed, but the pain remained, even showing signs of worsening. “Finally, the foreign doctors concluded it was a psychological issue and suggested I see a psychiatrist,” said Ms. S, her expression weary and helpless after fourteen years of struggle. “Actually, it’s not that I have psychological problems, but this prolonged pain has truly depressed me, leading to mild depression. At my most painful moments, I even contemplated suicide.”


        Part 2





In August 2024, accompanied by her husband, Ms. S walked into Shanghai Fourth People’s Hospital, affiliated with Tongji University, carrying her last glimmer of hope. The moment she stepped into the hospital, her heart was filled with anxiety and unease, as this was yet another hospital among the countless ones she had tried over the past decade. However, the warmth and kindness of the hospital’s triage nurse instantly gave her a sense of comfort. The nurse inquired in detail about her condition, quickly arranged for various examinations, and guided her to the dental department.

In the dental department, the doctor swiftly ruled out the possibility of odontogenic pain through detailed examinations and inquiries. Ms. S was somewhat surprised, as she had been misdiagnosed with dental issues multiple times abroad. Yet here, within just a few minutes, the doctor provided a clear conclusion and suggested she visit the cardiology department, where heart disease was also ruled out. That same day, she was referred to the neurology department, and the entire process was smooth and efficient. In the neurology department, the doctor arranged for a trigeminal nerve MRI scan. The results revealed a close relationship between the root of the right trigeminal nerve and a small artery, which might be the culprit behind her long-standing pain.

The neurologist’s detailed explanation rekindled hope in Ms. S. They recommended that she visit the expert clinic of Dr. Zhang Haitao, the deputy chief physician of neurosurgery, for further evaluation and treatment. On her way to the specialist clinic, Ms. S couldn’t help but marvel at the efficiency of China’s healthcare system. Through a multidisciplinary team (MDT) approach, patients are provided with more comprehensive and accurate diagnoses. This not only effectively avoids misdiagnosis and missed diagnoses but also significantly shortens the time to diagnosis, alleviating the suffering of patients.


Finally, Ms. S reached her ultimate destination within just a few days—the consultation room of Dr. Zhang Haitao, the deputy chief physician. Dr. Zhang warmly received her and meticulously inquired about her medical history and symptoms. Ms. S felt a long-lost sense of trust and care, and she began to question her previous medical experiences abroad. Why, despite all the advanced equipment and doctors, had she never found the root of her problem? Yet here, within just a few days, she received a clear and reasonable diagnosis.

After a detailed inquiry into her medical history, it was learned that the patient had initially experienced paroxysmal pain in the right cheek area ten years ago, which gradually extended to the upper posterior tooth roots and the area in front of the ear. In severe cases, the pain could also affect the lower posterior teeth, the side of the nose, the forehead, the brow, and the temples. More than seven years ago, the left posterior upper and lower tooth roots and the cheek area also began to frequently experience pain, all presenting as intense, electric shock-like radiating pain episodes, typically lasting from a few seconds to several minutes. Trigger points were located in the right cheek, upper posterior tooth roots, the side of the nose, and the left cheek and posterior upper and lower tooth roots. Pain was often triggered by eating, brushing teeth, and washing the face. Initially, she sought treatment at the dental department of a local hospital in her home country, where two upper posterior teeth on the right side and one upper posterior tooth on the left side were extracted. Later, local dental implants were performed, but the pain persisted without relief. During this period, she repeatedly sought treatment in the pain management department and took conventional painkillers, with little effect. About three months ago, she began taking gabapentin, metamizole, and antidepressants for control, but the results were still poor, and her symptoms worsened recently. The preliminary diagnosis suggested a high likelihood of primary trigeminal neuralgia. She was advised to stop taking gabapentin and metamizole and switch to a low dose of carbamazepine for a few days to observe the effect.

“Ms. S, we will do our utmost to help you. Let’s try carbamazepine first and see how it works,” Dr. Zhang said firmly. “This is a commonly used medication, and although it has some side effects, it might be effective in the short term.”

Ms. S deeply appreciated Dr. Zhang’s sincerity and professionalism. She knew she had finally found a medical team she could trust. This smooth medical experience not only brought her hope but also filled her with respect for China’s healthcare system.

A week later, Ms. S returned for a follow-up visit and was pleasantly surprised to find that her pain had significantly alleviated. She could eat normally again, and her mental state had improved considerably. However, the side effects of carbamazepine, such as dizziness and nausea, still caused discomfort. Based on Ms. S’s condition, treatment response, and imaging results, Dr. Zhang diagnosed her with “bilateral primary trigeminal neuralgia.” Due to the long course of the disease, gradual worsening of symptoms, and significant drug side effects, Dr. Zhang recommended surgical intervention. After thorough communication with Ms. S and her husband, they decided to proceed with further treatment in the neurosurgery department of Shanghai Fourth People’s Hospital.



image.png

Considering Ms. S’s unique situation, the neurosurgery team at Shanghai Fourth People’s Hospital decided to adopt a phased treatment approach. After a comprehensive departmental discussion, it was unanimously agreed that a staged treatment plan would be implemented. Based on the trigeminal nerve MRI scan results, which indicated a close relationship between the root of the right trigeminal nerve and blood vessels, a microvascular decompression surgery was deemed suitable for a definitive cure. For the left trigeminal nerve, where the relationship with blood vessels was unclear, robot-assisted percutaneous balloon compression (PBC) surgery was considered. After thoroughly explaining the condition and treatment plan to Ms. S and her husband, they agreed to the phased treatment approach. However, to avoid the risks associated with microvascular decompression surgery, it was decided to first proceed with robot-assisted percutaneous balloon compression surgery on the left trigeminal ganglion to maximally alleviate the current left-sided trigeminal neuralgia symptoms.

On August 27, 2014, the neurosurgery team at Shanghai Fourth People’s Hospital performed robot-assisted percutaneous balloon compression surgery (PBC) on Ms. S’s left trigeminal ganglion to relieve the current left-sided pain. Before the surgery, Director Zhang Zhiwen personally guided the procedure, with Deputy Chief Physician Zhang Haitao as the lead surgeon and Attending Physician Jiang Chenghao assisting. Director Li Cheng of the Anesthesiology Department ensured the smooth execution of the surgery. With the precise positioning of the robot and confirmation via C-arm X-ray, the surgical team successfully placed the balloon in the predetermined position. Slowly injecting the contrast agent, the balloon took on a “pear-shaped” form, achieving highly satisfactory results.

“I feel like the pain on the left side has completely disappeared. It’s truly miraculous!” Ms. S excitedly told Dr. Zhang after the surgery. On the first postoperative day, she was able to eat normally again, and her mental state was rejuvenated. Two days later, a follow-up cranial CT scan showed everything was normal, and Ms. S was discharged smoothly. Upon discharge, she and her husband expressed profound gratitude to the neurosurgery team, stating that if further treatment could not be effectively conducted in their home country, they would not hesitate to return to Shanghai to seek assistance here.


image.png

KeyNote:

Trigeminal neuralgia is a condition characterized by recurrent episodes of electric shock-like or knife-like pain affecting one or more sensory distribution areas of the facial trigeminal nerve. It is often described as “the most excruciating pain humans can endure” and is colloquially known as the “number one pain in the world.” Currently, the main clinical treatment methods include traditional medication control (such as carbamazepine and oxcarbazepine), microvascular decompression, percutaneous trigeminal ganglion radiofrequency thermocoagulation/balloon compression, and gamma knife therapy. Among these, microvascular decompression is the preferred and most effective long-term treatment for primary trigeminal neuralgia. However, it is not suitable for patients with poor overall health, advanced age, significant underlying medical conditions, or those who refuse craniotomy.

In recent years, the application of neuronavigation robots in percutaneous balloon compression (PBC) surgery has gained widespread recognition. The use of navigation robots ensures precise puncture, avoiding the risks of repeated puncture injuries and accidental damage to the internal carotid artery associated with blind punctures. This approach perfectly embodies the surgical principles of “precision and minimally invasive,” offering the unique advantages of short operation time, safety, effectiveness, and low cost. It complements microvascular decompression surgery effectively. Additionally, compared to radiofrequency thermocoagulation, patients undergoing PBC surgery do not need to endure severe pain during the procedure, experience less psychological stress, and have milder facial numbness post-surgery with reversible sensory recovery. This makes it particularly suitable for patients who cannot tolerate or are unwilling to undergo more invasive surgeries.







PART 03










 A Second Surgery, Completely Free from Pain, A Decade-Long Illness, Cured with Skill



Three months later, on the eve of Christmas 2024, Ms. S and her husband contacted Deputy Chief Physician Zhang Haitao once again.

“Dr. Zhang, we want to return to Shanghai to continue the treatment,” Ms. S’s husband said. “In Europe, the doctors gave the same advice as you, but we trust you more.”

Ms. S’s decision to travel thousands of miles to return was a testament to her immense trust in the neurosurgery team at Shanghai Fourth People’s Hospital. Director Zhang Zhiwen instructed the entire department to integrate resources from relevant departments within the hospital to ensure the best possible care for Ms. S. Under the meticulous arrangements of Deputy Chief Physician Zhang Haitao, Ms. S completed the routine preoperative examinations and underwent a follow-up trigeminal nerve MRI scan. The results showed that the relationship between the root of the right trigeminal nerve and the blood vessels remained close, clearly indicating the need for surgery. After a comprehensive departmental discussion, it was unanimously agreed to proceed with the previously planned staged treatment approach, performing microvascular decompression surgery on the right trigeminal nerve.

image.png


image.png






On December 26th, the neurosurgery team performed the surgery on Ms. S once again. Under the guidance of Director Zhang Zhiwen, Deputy Chief Physician Zhang Haitao led the operation, assisted by Attending Physician Xu Jiaotian. The anesthesia team, led by Directors Li Cheng and Chen Guozhong, provided full support, while Attending Physician Wang Wei conducted intraoperative neurophysiological monitoring throughout the procedure. Under the microscope, the surgical team found that the vascular compression matched the preoperative MRI findings exactly. They carefully examined the area using a neuroendoscope to ensure no additional vessels were overlooked. The surgery proceeded smoothly, and upon waking from anesthesia, Ms. S immediately felt complete relief from the pain on the right side of her face.

“I feel so much lighter,” Ms. S said to Dr. Zhang. “You are amazing. I truly don’t know how to thank you enough.”

In the first two days after the surgery, Ms. S experienced intermittent headaches, but she gradually recovered as time passed. A follow-up head CT scan showed normal intracranial conditions, and her overall recovery was excellent. One week post-surgery, there was no recurrence of facial pain, and the incision healed well, allowing for the sutures to be removed. When discharged, Ms. S and her husband were beaming with happiness.

“Finally, I’ve been freed from fourteen years of suffering,” Ms. S reflected. “You not only healed my body but also reignited my hope for life.”


image.png


Deputy Chief Physician Zhang Haitao explained that trigeminal neuralgia occurs in the distribution area of the trigeminal nerve in the head and face, typically starting from a specific point on the face, mouth, or jaw and spreading outward. The pain is characterized by sudden onset and cessation, occurring in paroxysmal episodes. Certain sensitive areas on the patient’s face, such as the lips, nasal wings, gums, and tongue, are known as trigger points. Daily activities like speaking, eating, brushing teeth, washing the face, shaving, combing hair, or even exposure to wind can trigger severe pain when these points are touched. This pain not only causes immense physical suffering but can also lead to mental distress, cautious behavior, and even suicidal tendencies.

Currently, the exact mechanism of primary trigeminal neuralgia is not fully understood. However, extensive research both domestically and internationally suggests that demyelination lesions in the area where the trigeminal nerve enters and exits the brainstem are the primary cause, with compression by small blood vessels in this region being a significant contributing factor. Microvascular decompression surgery involves identifying the blood vessels compressing the trigeminal nerve, relocating the responsible vessels, and placing insulating material between the vessels and the nerve to relieve the compression. Therefore, microvascular decompression surgery is the definitive and preferred treatment for primary trigeminal neuralgia.

Ms. S is an extremely rare case of bilateral primary trigeminal neuralgia, making her treatment relatively complex and challenging. In addition to adopting a staged surgical approach, the choice of surgical method is particularly crucial. While striving for the best therapeutic outcomes, it is also essential to prioritize safety and tailor individualized treatment plans for different types of patients, truly embodying a patient-centered approach.

This story is not just a triumph of medical technology but also a tale of trust, hope, and human warmth. Ms. S and her family, far from home, bravely faced the illness with their trust in the neurosurgery team at Shanghai Fourth People’s Hospital. In turn, the neurosurgery team, with their exceptional skills and meticulous care, brought new life to Ms. S. This cross-border trust and collaboration has become a beautiful chapter in the doctor-patient relationship.


image.png



Zhang Haitao

Deputy Chief Physician of Neurosurgery at Shanghai Fourth People’s Hospital, affiliated with Tongji University, and holder of a Medical Doctorate. He is a member of the Neurosurgery Professional Committee of the China Medicine Education Association, a member of the Spine and Spinal Cord Group of the Neurosurgery Branch of the Shanghai Medical Association, and a medical expert for labor capacity assessment in Hongkou District.

Dr. Zhang earned his master’s degree from the former Second Military Medical University and subsequently worked at the Fourth Medical Center of the People’s Liberation Army General Hospital for over a decade. During this time, he obtained his Ph.D. from the People’s Liberation Army Medical College (301 Hospital). He has participated in numerous research projects, including the National 863 Program, International Science and Technology Cooperation Projects, National Natural Science Foundation projects, and the Capital Health Development Research Special Project. He also led and completed a key clinical research funding project at the People’s Liberation Army General Hospital.

Dr. Zhang has published multiple core journal articles and SCI-indexed papers in domestic and international professional journals. He has been awarded the Second Prize for Military Medical Achievements, the Second Prize for Military Science and Technology Progress, and the Third Prize for Scientific and Technological Innovation from the China Medicine Education Association. Additionally, he has been granted one utility model patent.





关键词

Patient Stories

官方微信公众号